In Review

The Big Meal

3.5 out of 5 stars
3.5 out of 5 stars - 'Sweet Stuff'
San Jose Repertory Theatre
Directed by Kirsten Brandt
Review by Cy Ashley Webb

Cy Ashley Webb of Stark Insider reviews Dan LeFranc’s off Broadway play The Big Meal at San Jose Repertory Theatre.

The Big Meal at San Jose Repertory Theatre
Maddie (Sophia Grace Cuthbert), Nicole (Carrie Paff), Robbie (Nicolas Garcia), and Sam (Mark Anderson Phillips) enjoy a family meal together in San Jose Rep’s ‘The Big Meal’ through June 1.

Part of scenic designer Nina Ball’s magic lies in creating places that you’ve been before. Surely you remember that dimly lit diner with the brown and yellow tile floor that has a fake Tiffany lamp hanging over each brown vinyl booth. However, you probably never spent the same amount of time in that dive as the characters in The Big Meal, a Dan LeFranc play that just opened at the San Jose Rep.

Action cycles across multiple generations, all of who convene at the diner. This restaurant setting made sense to LeFranc, son of a waitress and restaurant manager. At the outset, we see fragments of failed dates between the leading couple-to-be, Sam and Nicole, each date separated by an auditory signal. This approach makes for fast and funny action. However, confusion sets in as we see the same actor morph into different characters, and single characters played by different actors.

It’s not a stretch to believe that this confusion was intentional, perhaps as a way of pointing out that children often never get all that far from the tree that bore them. However, once you get past that first generation, characters blur and cease to be distinct. Cross talk at the table makes it unclear exactly which generation is speaking. This isn’t necessarily bad because it makes for a fast-paced evening. Do be warned though: if you’re looking for a child-free night out, look elsewhere because you’re never too far from one more onslaught of noisy children barreling through the diner.

Theater Review: The Big Meal, San Jose Rep
Nicole (Jessica Lynn Carroll) and Sam (Aaron Wilton) begin to fall in love.

As Nicole, Carrie Paff was particularly outstanding. One senses she had a clearly defined sense of what made Nicole tick, and perhaps even more importantly, respected her. Having earned this credibility, Paff cashes in on it in subsequent scenes when she’s morphed into the 20-something granddaughter of Nicole (now played by a different actress), complete with the clear eyes of youth, talking to her very aged grandmother.

MORE STARK INSIDER: Gia Coppola brings teen nihilism to big screen thanks to James Franco (Video)

The emotional impact of all this action ripples across the audience, particularly during the past twenty minutes when sniffles become audible as yet another character removes himself from the table, signifying that they’ve passed on. It’s almost as if once you think you finally have a sense of a character, they’re bound to die.

The Big Meal will be on stage until June 1. Summer productions at the San Jose Rep include Landscape with Weapon and The Complete History of Comedy (abridged).

San Francisco Theater news, reviews, photos, videosStark Insider Arts & Culture

Theater Reviews:

Mark Kenward in ‘Nantucket’ (The Marsh Berkeley)

More Cole Porter: ‘DuBarry Was a Lady’ (42nd Street Moon)

Back in the USSR with ‘The Letters’ (Aurora Theatre Company)


Art of Filmmaking with Gia Coppola and  ‘Palo Alto’

I am Not a Genuine Black Man – Brian Copeland

Bruce Vilanch talks Tina Fey, “being sick of me”, Broadway revival

Cy Ashley Webb
Cy spent the ‘80’s as a bench scientist, the tech boom doing intellectual property law, and the first decade of the millennium, aspiring to be the world’s oldest grad student at Stanford where she is interested in political martyrdom. Presently, she enjoys writing for Stark Insider and the SF Examiner, hanging out at Palo Alto Children's Theatre, and participating in various political activities. Democracy is not a spectator sport! Cy is a SFBATCC member.