Skip to content
Stark Insider
  • Culture
  • Filmmaking/Tech
  • Atelier Stark Films
News Tech

HomePod delay a massive miss by Apple

Delaying HomePod to 2018 means Apple will lose buyers to Amazon and Google this holiday season. It could be a very costly decision.

BY Clinton Stark — 11.20.2017

Apple HomePod delayed to 2018 - A huge miss, cedes market share to Amazon and Google.

Amazon already sells about 7 out of every 10 smart speakers. Its line-up of Echo-branded devices, featuring the seemingly ubiquitous Alexa voice assistant, have been, according to Amazon, its best selling product of all time.

And, the market for smart speakers (assistants) is estimated to hit $13 billion by 2024 (source: Global Market Insights). That’s only about 6 years away. The race is on.

I can only imagine the pressure in those internal Apple meetings discussing whether or not to delay the HomePod. This is not a million dollar opportunity. It’s a billion dollar one.

Apple, though, doesn’t have skin in the game. It was supposed to. And now the segment is taking off and Apple has no answer to the Amazon Echo or Google Home voice-activated smart speaker.

We got a glimpse of its smart speaker entrant, the HomePod, earlier this year. As we might guess, Apple is going up-market, with a $349 starting price. That’s par for the course, and hasn’t hurt premium-positioned iPhones priced at and even beyond the $1,000 (USD) mark.

Originally, CEO Tim Cook and team said the HomePod would ship some time in December, just in time for the holidays. Last week, some bad news: Apple was delaying the HomePod until 2018. “We need a little more time before it’s ready for our customers.” Ouch.

Just the two of us. This holiday season, most buyers will choose either a Google Home or Amazon Echo (Dot pictured) smart speaker. Meantime, Apple delayed its competitor, the HomePod, to 2018.

I can only imagine the pressure in those internal Apple meetings discussing whether or not to delay the HomePod. This is not a million dollar opportunity. It’s a billion dollar one. Capital B. Not necessarily because Apple will generate that much in sales from smart speakers, but because it’s the new trojan horse for smart home automation. Get a speaker into a home, and you have untold opportunities:

  • People tend to buy more than one smart speaker (Amazon, for example, recently enabled a whole home audio feature for Echo)
  • Voice is becoming the defacto method for interacting with the smart home — Amazon with Alexa is winning the race early on
  • Smart speakers further enforce Google (Google Home) and Amazon (Echo) ecosystems
  • E-commerce via voice is at the cusp
  • Music is the #1 reason buyers cite they buy a smart speaker — it follows that drive lucrative subscription sales for Google Play Music and Amazon Prime Music

So I think when we talk about selling a single smart speaker, be it a Google Home or Echo Dot, we’re talking about much more than a single hardware sale. This is as big as the early days of the iPhone. Recall the iPhone spawned the App economy.

Now that Apple won’t have the HomePod in time for the holidays, what will happen to its would-be buyers?

Currently, you can’t even put a deposit down on a HomePod so that means the money will likely go elsewhere. I doubt those who earmarked a HomePod either for themselves or as a holiday gift will wait. After all, we’re living in the era of instant gratification. Fully functional Amazon Echo and Google Home speakers are available here today. They can play music, yes. They can also play the role of smart home hub — quite well, in fact. Plus, they’re much cheaper. Why wait for HomePod?

… we’re talking about much more than a single hardware sale. This is as big as the early days of the iPhone. Recall the iPhone spawned the App economy.

If in fact, say, 80-90% of the money that would’ve gone to the HomePod goes to, instead, Amazon and Google (and a smaller amount to companies like Sonos who also make an Alexa-enabled speaker with the new Sonos One) what happens in 2018? I doubt new Echo and Google Home owners will be willing to switch anytime soon, even if/when HomePod ships. This is what Amazon gets so well. Vendor lock-in is key. Get to market early, and proliferate with several products (Echo, Dot, Show, etc.) at various price points, offer bundled discounts and invade the home at all costs. Sure, not everything works. Thanks to the cloud, though, Amazon has been rolling out regular updates which fix bugs and add new features.

Fortunately for Apple, the iPhone X has been well received. I expect it will sell well. Early forecasts seem positive.

Regardless, the HomePod delay is a massive miss for Apple.

Tags:Amazon Amazon Echo Apple Google Google Home Smart Home Sonos

Related Stories

The Third Mind AI Summit returns to Sonoma wine country June 30 to July 2, 2026. Three days exploring how humans and AI agents collaborate as equals.

Save the Date: The Third Mind AI Summit 2026 Heads to Sonoma

News
MacBook Pro running Claude Code in Visual Studio Code with an autonomous coding prompt, demonstrating how to unlock long multi-hour runs from an AI coding agent

Quick Tip: How to Get Claude Code to Run Autonomously for Hours

News
Which Molty blind LLM study: a four-week single-blind crossover experiment testing whether users can detect the language model powering an always-on AI agent when the memory system stays constant. Results show no statistically significant difference across MiniMax M2.7, Kimi K2.5, GLM-5, and Gemma 4 31B.

Which Molty? Our Blind LLM Study Says Memory Beats Model

News
2026 Artificial Intelligence Index Report from Stanford HAI

Stanford's 2026 AI Index: Where AI Actually Stands (report)

News

More in News →

Clinton Stark

Filmmaker and editor at Stark Insider, covering arts, AI & tech, and indie film. Inspired by Bergman, slow cinema and Chipotle. Often found behind the camera or in the edit bay. Peloton: ClintTheMint.

Short Films
Loni Stark - A West Coast Adventure - A Lifetime in the Making - Stark Insider

Stark Insider
  • CULTURE
  • BEST OF AI
  • FILMMAKING/TECH
  • ATELIER STARK FILMS
  • HUMANxAI SYMBIOSIS
THE STARK COLLECTIVE
  • THE STARK CO
  • STARK INSIDER
  • STARKMIND
  • ATELIER STARK
© Copyright 2005-2026 BLG Media LLC. v2.19.0
  • Review Policy and Shipping
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • About