Skip to content
Stark Insider
  • Culture
  • Filmmaking/Tech
  • Atelier Stark Films
News Theater and Stage

Theater review: ‘Cinderella’ enchants, casts magical spell of non-stop laugher for entire family

BY Clinton Stark — 12.21.2009

l-r, Abbie Rhone (Stepsister), Melvina Hayes (Stepmother), Martin Grizzell (Stepsister), and dancers

Cinderella

Stark Insider

4★

4 out of 5 stars

Location: African-American Shakespeare Company

Directed by: Sherri Young

You’ve seen Cinderella before, but not like this laugh-out-loud, delightful family rendition by the African-American Shakespeare Company.

The famous rag-to-riches story gets a soulful makeover, taking place in the bayous of Louisiana. The traditional elements are all here—the slipper, the nasty stepsisters, the prince, and the pursuit of love and destiny. But Director Sherri Young (an M.F.A. graduate from the American Conservatory Theater) give the material a fresh update that is pure magic beginning to end.

And funny!

The standing-room only audience was abuzz the entire evening and included lots of children that stared at the stage in wide-eyed wonder. In between wild bursts of laughter that is.

The set is simple, yet effectively detailed with lighting, a beautiful horse-drawn cart we see only for a moment before intermission, and the kitchen from Cinderella’s home where she is enslaved to household chores.

It’s a man, baby!

Young Cinderella: Jazara Metcalf. Photographer: Marty Sohl.

I think it’s been a while since I’ve laughed this hard. Having a whole theater-full of people doing the same certainly adds fuel to the fire. And it’s contagious. The primary reason is the brilliant (and somewhat crazy!) idea to cast the stepsisters as two men in drag. I wasn’t too sure this was a good idea at first. But when they saunter on stage with alternatively bemused and confused expressions, exaggerated body language and outrageous voices, it became evident this was going to be a hoot.

About 90 minutes long the production moves along quickly, and keeps us engaged as the Godmother sits with two nieces and recounts the story of Cinderella. Later, she takes matters into her own hands, steps into the middle of the play, and insists Cinderella straighten herself out and attend the ball—with a bit of magic, of course.

“Magic sometimes takes time,” she says, and after a quick costume change, Cinderella emerges in a stunning, white, gown.

New Artistic Director L. Peter Callender

The ball is the perfect setting for plenty of comedy too. We get some crazy dancing, beautiful dancing, hijinks, mistaken identity, and, of course, the wild stepsisters trying to manage in high heels.

One minor issue:  the stepsisters are so wildly amusing that the actors need to possibly tone down their comical mannerisms just a tad when important scenes and dialog are taking place across the stage so that the main storyline is not detracted.

Much has been written (and celebrated) about having a black Cinderella. And it’s a pleasure to see it work so well. There is no forcing here, or wedging other messages into the story. I was pleased to see a racial mix at the ballroom—this isn’t The Wiz thankfully. It is simply a classic tale told proudly (and did I mention, comically?).

Cinderella runs to December 27. I highly recommend you grab young ones everywhere around you to go see this unique, entertaining production.

Cinderella
African-American Shakespeare Company
4 out of 5 stars
Directed by Sherri Young

Tags:San Francisco

Related Stories

Alamo Drafthouse New Mission in San Francisco, to be renamed the Christopher Nolan Cinema

Alamo Drafthouse to Rename San Francisco's New Mission the Christopher Nolan Cinema

News
A hand rings the opening bell on a stock exchange trading floor as OpenAI and Anthropic head to the public markets

OpenAI and Anthropic File for IPOs in the Same Week. The AI Industry Just Changed.

News
VS Code IDE on a remote AI Lab workstation showing Claude Code on the left triaging linter logic and Codex on the right running a parallel customer UX review of Meaning Memory v3.15.1rc1, with five modified files in the source control panel.

I Built an Agentic Memory Engine With 8 AI Collaborators. Here's How.

News
The Third Mind AI Summit returns to Sonoma wine country June 30 to July 2, 2026. Three days exploring how humans and AI agents collaborate as equals.

Save the Date: The Third Mind AI Summit 2026 Heads to Sonoma

News

More in News →

Clinton Stark

Filmmaker and editor at Stark Insider, covering arts, AI & tech, and indie film. Inspired by Bergman, slow cinema and Chipotle. Often found behind the camera or in the edit bay. Peloton: ClintTheMint.

Short Films
Loni Stark - A West Coast Adventure - A Lifetime in the Making - Stark Insider

Stark Insider
  • CULTURE
  • BEST OF AI
  • FILMMAKING/TECH
  • ATELIER STARK FILMS
  • HUMANxAI SYMBIOSIS
THE STARK COLLECTIVE
  • THE STARK CO
  • STARK INSIDER
  • STARKMIND
  • ATELIER STARK
© Copyright 2005-2026 BLG Media LLC. v2.19.0
  • Review Policy and Shipping
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • About