Skip to content
Stark Insider
  • Culture
  • Filmmaking/Tech
  • Atelier Stark Films
Culture Theater and Stage

Order, balance, transformation and beauty: PBO does Italy

If your point of reference to recorder music is the more staid Renaissance music, Verbruggen’s performance will stand such notions on their head. She propelled the Sammartini forward with the vivacity and exuberance that makes this music seem like such a gift.

BY Cy Ashley Webb — 11.21.2011

PBO

Philharmonia Baroque Orchestra

Stark Insider

4★

4 out of 5 stars
Additional Info:

  • Guest conductor: Ottavio Dantone<br/>
  • Marion Verbruggen & the Italian Baroque Recorder
  • Thursday November 17th – Sunday November 20th.

Newcomers to Baroque invariably ask about the differences between Italian, French, German and English music. After all, this distinction is used so frequently that it acts as musical shorthand. With their current all-Italian program and an upcoming all-English program, the Philharmonia Baroque Orchestra is well on the way of answering that question.

The current program, featuring works by Arcangelo Corelli, Francesco Geminiani, Antonio Vivaldi, Guiseppe Samartini, and Alessandro Scarlatti is an excellent introduction to the world of the Italian baroque. It’s easy to forget that the Baroque began in Italy. Germany may have had the organ makers, but Cremona was the unrivaled center for violins, being home to Nicolò Amati (1596–1684), Antonio Stradivari (1644–1737), and Bartolomeo Guarneri, del Gesù (1698 – 1744). Even the word “baroque” is derived from the Italian “barocco,” meaning bizarre. And what a bizarre transition it must have been, when contrasting strands of musical textures replaced the more monolithic voicing of Renaissance music. We so think in terms of harmony based on root motions of fifths that it’s hard to imagine that this wasn’t always the case.

The current all-Italian program even brings a new Italian guest conductor, Ottavio Dantone. Like Lars Ulrik Mortensen did last year (and Musical Director Nicholas McGegan did earlier this year), Dantone conducted from the harpsichord.  With no brass, woodwinds or percussion, this was a small stage – and seemed more intimate in the bargain.

Verbruggen MarionThe star of the evening, however was Marion Verbruggen. Verbruggen joined the PBO for Vivaldi’s Concerto for Alto Recorder in F Major “La tempesta di mare” and Sammartini’s  Concerto for Soprano recorder in F Major. If you thought you knew something about recorder going into this concert, Verbruggen quickly disabused you of that thought. Grove Music states that “because of its construction with open finger-holes and duct mouthpiece, the recorder came to be considered the woodwind instrument capable of producing the widest range of techniques and special effects.” Marion Verbruggen seemed to demonstrate all of these. I’d never thought of the recorder as a particularly dynamic instrument, but Verbruggen’s performance of the  Sammartini  Concerto for Soprano recorder in F Major burst the floodgates with rivulets of notes peeling off to every side. I never knew that soprano recorder could hit notes so high – or be played so fast! If your point of reference to recorder music is the more staid Renaissance music, Verbruggen’s performance will stand such notions on their head. She propelled the Sammartini forward with the vivacity and exuberance that makes this music seem like such a gift.

Next to Verbruggen’s performance, the gem of the evening was the Concerto Grosso by Gregori. Exquisitely paced and balanced, it drew out the best of this group. Concertmaster Carla Moore played with such a warmth and timbre that one imagines some part of the universe being just a little bit better afterwards. This music can be that powerful.

The PBO’s will perform the Bach’s Mass in B Minor next month, joined by countertenor Daniel Taylor. Taylor performed with the PBO this time last year during their exquisite Messiah. Seeing him again with the PBO promises to be a delight.

San Francisco Bay Area Arts and CulturePhilharmonia Baroque Orchestra

4 out of 5 stars (Smashing)

Guest conductor: Ottavio Dantone
Marion Verbruggen & the Italian Baroque Recorder
Thursday November 17th – Sunday November 20th.

Tags:San Francisco

Related Stories

Six Ruth Asawa looped-wire sculptures suspended against white wall with circular shadows

The Wire Remembers

Culture
Loni Stark responding to AI Agent questions ahead of The Third Mind Summit in Loreto Mexico.

When Agents Answer Back: Documenting Divergence in Human-AI Collaboration

Culture
Loreto Baja California Sur - site of The Third Mind Summit 2025

The Third Mind Summit: Pre-Event Field Notes on Human-AI Symbiosis

Culture
CellarChat AI wine-pairing interface on a mobile phone, showing prompts like ‘What should I open for dinner with lamb?’ and ‘Which of my wines are ready to drink?’

CellarTracker Launches AI-Powered Wine Recommendations with CellarChat

Culture

More in Culture →

Cy Ashley Webb

Cy spent the ‘80’s as a bench scientist, the tech boom doing intellectual property law, and the first decade of the millennium, aspiring to be the world’s oldest grad student at Stanford where she is interested in political martyrdom. Presently, she enjoys writing for Stark Insider and the SF Examiner, hanging out at Palo Alto Children's Theatre, and participating in various political activities. Democracy is not a spectator sport! Cy is a SFBATCC member.

Loni Stark - A West Coast Adventure - A Lifetime in the Making - Stark Insider

Stark Insider
  • CULTURE
  • BEST OF AI
  • FILMMAKING/TECH
  • ATELIER STARK FILMS
  • HUMANxAI SYMBIOSIS
THE STARK COLLECTIVE
  • THE STARK CO
  • STARK INSIDER
  • STARKMIND
  • ATELIER STARK
© Copyright 2005-2026 BLG Media LLC. v2.19.0
  • Review Policy and Shipping
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • About