Theater Review: ‘Superior Donuts’

However, inasmuch as these darker threads are woven into a larger fabric, they also raise the possibility of connection without getting maudlin.

l-r Arthur (Howard Swain) and Franco (Lance Gardner) in the regional premiere of SUPERIOR DONUTS at TheatreWorks. Photo Credit: Tracy Martin
l-r Arthur (Howard Swain) and Franco (Lance Gardner) in the regional premiere of SUPERIOR DONUTS at TheatreWorks. Photo Credit: Tracy Martin
In Review

Superior Donuts

4 out of 5 stars
4 out of 5 stars - 'Smashing'
TheatreWorks

Mountain View Center for the Performing Arts
Directed by Leslie Martinson
October 9th - October 31st
www.theatreworks.org
Review by
l-r Arthur (Howard Swain) and Franco (Lance  Gardner) in the regional premiere of SUPERIOR  DONUTS at TheatreWorks.  Photo Credit: Tracy Martin
l-r Arthur (Howard Swain) and Franco (Lance Gardner) in the regional premiere of SUPERIOR DONUTS at TheatreWorks. Photo Credit: Tracy Martin

Take ’60’s retread Arthur Przbyszewsk, 20-something black counter-help Franco Wicks, a lady cop and a Russian immigrant, bring them together in a Chicago Uptown donut shot, infuse the mix with equal parts enthusiasm and ennui; and the result is an incredibly funny, high energy drama that only Tracy Letts could write. Rich and chewy, and longer on substance than the eponymous confection, TheatreWorks did justice to this phenomenal script.

The success of this play is all the more surprising because its harder to pull off redemption stories. Having invested a considerable amount of time and energy into pulling off the knowing look without revealing exasperation, we don’t like our sophistication and cynicism challenged in ways that can’t be resolved by intellectual gamesmanship. However, this is the territory covered by Superior Donuts. I suspect at least some in the audience will find Arthur Przbyszewski’s character a wee bit unsettling. However, inasmuch as these darker threads are woven into a larger fabric, they also raise the possibility of connection without getting maudlin. This is the magic of theatre and why we keep coming back. This is why Superior Donuts works so well.

l-r Officer Randy Osteen (Julia Brothers) and Arthur  Przybyszewski (Howard Swain) in the regional  premiere of SUPERIOR DONUTS  at TheatreWorks.  Photo Credit: Mark Kitaoka
l-r Officer Randy Osteen (Julia Brothers) and Arthur Przybyszewski (Howard Swain) in the regional premiere of SUPERIOR DONUTS at TheatreWorks. Photo Credit: Mark Kitaoka

The interplay between shop owner Arthur Przbyszewski) (Howard Swain), immigrant businessman Max Tarasov (Seren Oliver) and the new hire Franco Wick (Lance Gardner) was fascinating to watch as each pushed each other into more and more polarized positions. Whereas Swain is so physically lethargic he can barely sit on a counter stool, Gardner’s high energy animates the entire stage. Tarasov struggles with his English but is nonetheless incredbly revealing, while Gardner is of few words. Each actor pushed their character to its limits, almost going too far before pulling back. This tension saved the characters from becoming cardboard cutout and gave rise to some of the funnier moments of the evening. Franco’s upstart nagging about Arthur’s wardrobe brought down the house when he urged Arthur to lose the ponytail and ditch the patchouli because it smells like cat piss. The ante is upped when Franco tells him to dump the cat in response to his defense patchouli denial.

Lance Gardner as Franco in the regional premiere  of SUPERIOR DONUTS at TheatreWorks.  Photo Credit: Tracy Martin
Lance Gardner as Franco in the regional premiere of SUPERIOR DONUTS at TheatreWorks. Photo Credit: Tracy Martin

This review would be incomplete without mention of newcomer Jonathan Deline. During his brief appearance on stage, Deline’s impressive body armor spoke volumes that would have been impossible for a lesser actor to convey. Hopefully, we will see more of this young man in the years to come.

Set designer Tom Langguth brought a whole world together on stage that was as rich in detail and as deep as the characters themselves. In a play as tied to a particular city and particular location, the details had to be right. However, getting it right also meant making it universal,which is where Langguth’s genius shown. If you’ve above a certain age, you’ve been in that doughnut shop. Care was obviously spent on the small details like the cutaway to the storage room, the hanging string hanging to wrap up boxes and the dollar bill and small photos clustered by the register. The rumbling El over the shop warded off the claustrophobia that can set in when the action is confined to a single interior set.

l-r Arthur Przybyszewski (Howard Swain), Max Tarasov (Søren Oliver), Randy Osteen (Julia  Brothers), and Lady Boyle (Joan Mankin) in the  regional premiere of SUPERIOR DONUTS at  TheatreWorks.  Photo Credit: Tracy Martin
l-r Arthur Przybyszewski (Howard Swain), Max Tarasov (Søren Oliver), Randy Osteen (Julia Brothers), and Lady Boyle (Joan Mankin) in the regional premiere of SUPERIOR DONUTS at TheatreWorks. Photo Credit: Tracy Martin

Superior Donuts continues through the end of the month – and is well worth taking in. The warmth of the donut shop makes this a perfect play for autumnal shadows grow longer.

Superior Donuts
TheatreWorks
Mountain View Center for the Performing Arts
4 out of 5 Stars
Leslie Martinson
October 9th – October 31st
www.theatreworks.org

Explore. Create. Live. Follow Stark Insider on Twitter and Facebook. Join our 9,000 subscribers who read SI on tablets and smartphones on Google Newsstand. Prefer video? Subscribe to 
Stark Insider on YouTube, the largest arts & travel channel in San Francisco.
Share with your friends










Submit
Previous articlePlay about world’s first woman architect Julia Morgan coming to Berkeley
Next articleMicrosoft reveals Windows Phone 7 handsets
Cy Ashley Webb
Cy spent the ‘80’s as a bench scientist, the tech boom doing intellectual property law, and the first decade of the millennium, aspiring to be the world’s oldest grad student at Stanford where she is interested in political martyrdom. Presently, she enjoys writing for Stark Insider and the SF Examiner, hanging out at Palo Alto Children's Theatre, and participating in various political activities. Democracy is not a spectator sport! Cy is a SFBATCC member.