Live from Cinequest: 3D cinema, filmmakers follow the money (and hype)

So you decide to throw a 3D Super Bowl. But what happens when 15 friends show up and you only have 14 pairs of 3D glasses (and they’re not even designer!)?

That, and sourcing equipment and skills, were just a few of the problems discussed at today’s Cinequest Maverick Artist & Innovator forum on 3D.

A panel member astutely pointed out a quick trip to Fry’s Electronics would easily avoid the aforementioned “social disaster.”

Avatar is not only the billion dollar poster child for all things 3D, it also represents a gambit of an industry looking for its next big paycheck. And it’s harder than ever with all sorts of entertainment—video games, the Internet, mobile entertainment—vying for consumer’s pocketbooks.

So it was with great interest that I attended today’s panel at the Camera 12, downtown San Jose.

“A whole bunch of 3D cameras are coming, which means a whole lot of bad 3D films.”

The theater was packed, and there were equal amounts of confusion and excitement in the air about the technology and its potential impact on the film industry; especially for the small independents who were well represented in the room.

The panel included a balanced mix of producers, vendors and studios: Kelly A. Williamson (CEO, CritterPix Studios and Director, Ollie the Otter), moderator Laurence Thorpe (Marketing Executive, Canon USA), Michael MacKay (Renaissance Center), Charlotte Huggins (Producer, Mad Media Entertainment), and Greg Boren (Panasonic).

Discussion ranged the gamut from technical challenges and new camera technology through to distribution and assessing when and where to even use 3D.

“A whole bunch of 3D cameras are coming, which means a whole lot of bad 3D films.”

One thing is definitive: 3D is a big deal. And whether consumers ultimately want it or not—and Avatar suggests that the answer is a Billion dollar yes—it’s coming, with mega-hype in tow.

According to Charlotte Huggins, the upcoming $100 million remake of Clash of the Titans is being converted into 3D. The time constraints are enormous. In this case, only 13 weeks. “Everybody on the planet is working on it,” she says. “We’re all very eager to see how this movie looks.”

Huggins also said she counted about 23 companies around the world providing 2D to 3D conversion services.

Kelly Williamson said 3D gave him the edge when it came to getting attention for his short, Ollie the Otter. Because only his film and one other employed the technology, there was a spirited competition among sales agents to buy distribution rights at a recent overseas festival.

Oh, and, yes, it was a very Hollywood panel: everyone it seemed had worked on The Hurt Locker, and was friends with James Cameron (not to mention George Lucas… or just “George”).

Let’s do lunch!

Highlights and Sound Bytes

  • “Don’t fatigue the audience, still important to tell a story.”
  • 3D is “akin to optical illusion compared to normal cinema.”
  • “When people see each other in 3D they start reaching out; there is something different about that world – not quite the same as real world”
  • 3D tools have come a long way compared to the good old days (i.e. 6 months ago, now “you can change convergence in post. Rotation is easy, etc. … easily fixed now that it’s really gotten much easier to finish your movie”
  • Charlotte Huggins: “These are just all fonts.” (3D)
  • “Where does human vision break down from 3D to 2D and how do you apply that sports?”
  • Broadcast doesn’t know how to send 3D (cable can); all setting up networks, but live television is a challenge.
  • The NFL has been making 3D football for four years
  • Star Wars converted; George Lucas shots were already lined up; can’t even tell it wasn’t shot in 2D

Parting Shot

For me, 3D is already way over-hyped.

Don’t get me wrong, I think it has a place, and it can wow the socks off the most jaded of movie-goer. However, let’s not fall into the trap of confusing next generation technology with strong storytelling and classic filmmaking.

3D is still just a tool. Granted it could change the game and pave the way for decades of renewed studio profits, however, let’s all hope the fundamentals of making a good film remain. Ultimately that’s where our money should go.

Explore. Create. Live. Follow Stark Insider on Twitter and Facebook. Join our 9,000 subscribers who read SI on tablets and smartphones on Google Newsstand. Prefer video? Subscribe to 
Stark Insider on YouTube, the largest arts & travel channel in San Francisco.
  • Hi Clinton. I just read your take on stereo 3D and the number of 2D to 3D conversion companies around the world. I think if you dig somewhat further you’ll find that all but literally a handful are actually capable of producing an entire feature film let alone a high quality 3D demo. Legend Films just completed a substantial amount of Alice In Wonderland and it looks spectacular. While it might be considered apples and oranges, I’d hold it up to Avatar any day in terms of quality 3D and in fact some reviewers already have. Would love to hear what you think of it. Currently we’re producing three feature films for one of the majors. Yes, it’s happening. If you’re ever in San Diego, please stop by our studio. I’d love to show you some amazing 3D and how it all comes together.

    Best,
    Barry

    Barry B. Sandrew, Ph.D.
    Founder and President/COO
    Legend3D, a Legend Films company

  • Barry B. Sandrew

    Hi Clinton. I just read your take on stereo 3D and the number of 2D to 3D conversion companies around the world. I think if you dig somewhat further you’ll find that all but literally a handful are actually capable of producing an entire feature film let alone a high quality 3D demo. Legend Films just completed a substantial amount of Alice In Wonderland and it looks spectacular. While it might be considered apples and oranges, I’d hold it up to Avatar any day in terms of quality 3D and in fact some reviewers already have. Would love to hear what you think of it. Currently we’re producing three feature films for one of the majors. Yes, it’s happening. If you’re ever in San Diego, please stop by our studio. I’d love to show you some amazing 3D and how it all comes together.

    Best,
    Barry

    Barry B. Sandrew, Ph.D.
    Founder and President/COO
    Legend3D, a Legend Films company

  • Sherman Heidelberg

    Peace Yes I guess if you plan on being a great film maker you must adjust and learn how to change of new technology.I’m interested in keeping up with your projects. If there is any advice you could give a beginning film maker like myself,please inform me.I’m willing to travel to conventions and visit on site sets etc. Thanks again for your time and i hope to hear back from you. Thank You and continue success.
    unda07@hotmail.com Tariq Unda Lyne Films

  • Sherman Heidelberg

    Peace Yes I guess if you plan on being a great film maker you must adjust and learn how to change of new technology.I’m interested in keeping up with your projects. If there is any advice you could give a beginning film maker like myself,please inform me.I’m willing to travel to conventions and visit on site sets etc. Thanks again for your time and i hope to hear back from you. Thank You and continue success.
    unda07@hotmail.com Tariq Unda Lyne Films