Skip to content
Stark Insider
  • Culture
  • Filmmaking/Tech
  • Atelier Stark Films
Film Reviews Independent Film

‘The Butcher’s Wife’ a gritty masterpiece (film review)

The acting is gritty and raw, none of the surreal gloss that covers big budget Hollywood numbers.

BY Loni Stark — 10.03.2011

The Butcher's Wife
The Butcher's Wife

The Butcher's Wife (2010) formerly Wangliang's Ideal

Stark Insider

5★

5 out of 5 stars

Location: Mill Valley Film Festival 2011 (North American Premiere)

Directed by: Gao Xiongjie

Starring: Fang Ye, Tang Huihua

Additional Info:

  • 119 minutes (Mandarin with English subtitles)
The Butcher's Wife
The Butcher's Wife

The Butcher’s Wife (formerly titled, Wangliang’s Ideal…I like the new title) is ultimately a haunting tale of unrelenting obsessions, and what happens when these are constrained by reality. If you are looking for fun, lighthearted amusement, this is not it. If you are seeking a thought provoking, gut-wrenching, heart-ripping odyssey that you will remember for weeks, months and even years after, this is a tour de force.

Director and screenwriter Gao Xiongjie’s conjures up main characters with such complexity and grit, I was captivated in the first few minutes of this 2 hour masterpiece.

The story centers around Liang (Fang Ye), a butcher and his wife Qiao (Tang Huihua) who live in a village about four hours bus ride from the Chinese city of Hangzhou. Liang dreams of building a simple, normal life with his wife and a future child in the farm community where he slaughters pigs for a living. His wife, Qiao though is determined to pass her college entrance exams on her fourth attempt and refuses to consummate the marriage for fear of getting pregnant.

The acting is gritty and raw, none of the surreal gloss that covers big budget Hollywood numbers. While real, it is apparent the storyline is expertly crafted. On reflection symbolism and foreshadowing become apparent, but only in hind-sight. It doesn’t make the film predicable in the moment. Yet, like fine wine, gives a long finish that reverberates in the mind and heart.

The empathy I quickly developed for both the butcher and his wife bound me to the film. Watching the fate of the couple became my personal obsession and as the film spun into deeper and darker places, I could not tear my eyes from the screen until the final tragic climax.

Related Stories

Christine in her red raincoat in the opening scene of Don't Look Now (1973), directed by Nicolas Roeg

The best horror movies of all time, re-screened for 2026

Film Reviews
Surgeons in caps and masks operate together in a Gaza hospital in the documentary American Doctor

'American Doctor' Review: Three U.S. Physicians Bear Witness in Gaza

Film Reviews
Tecla Insolia and Romana Maggiora Vergano laughing together on a sunlit bus in a scene from Idda

Idda Review: Two Friends, Old Secrets and the Breath of Mount Etna

Film Reviews
Sophie Thatcher in Her Private Hell, wearing a red high-collared jacket and jewelled teardrop eye makeup against a magenta neon curtain.

Her Private Hell Review: Nicolas Winding Refn's Return, In Five Words

Film Reviews

More in Film Reviews →

Loni Stark

Loni Stark is an artist at Atelier Stark, psychology researcher, and technologist whose work explores the intersection of identity, creativity, and technology. Through StarkMind, she investigates human-AI collaboration and the emerging dynamics of agentic systems, research that informs both her academic work and creative practice. A self-professed foodie and adventure travel enthusiast, she collaborates on visual storytelling projects with Clinton Stark for Stark Insider. Her insights are shaped by her role at Adobe, influencing her explorations into the human-tech relationship. It's been said her laugh can still be heard from San Jose up to the Golden Gate Bridge—unless sushi, her culinary Kryptonite, has momentarily silenced her.

Loni Stark - A West Coast Adventure - A Lifetime in the Making - Stark Insider

Stark Insider
  • CULTURE
  • BEST OF AI
  • FILMMAKING/TECH
  • ATELIER STARK FILMS
  • HUMANxAI SYMBIOSIS
THE STARK COLLECTIVE
  • THE STARK CO
  • STARK INSIDER
  • STARKMIND
  • ATELIER STARK
© Copyright 2005-2026 BLG Media LLC. v2.21.5
  • Review Policy and Shipping
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • About