Windows 8 and Dr. Jekyll – Scaring off developers?

And you thought Google's Android fragmentation was an issue.

Metro is pretty, but will it increase development efforts for Win 8 software?
Metro is pretty, but will it increase development efforts for Win 8 software?

Dr. Jekyll, your new OS awaits.

Microsoft Windows 8 is not even here yet, and it’s already facing a huge challenge: its split personality.

If you haven’t been following some of the recent headlines about the consumer and developer previews, then here’s a quick recap regarding the much ballyhooed new look. Essentially Win 8 is two user interfaces in one. Think of it as your garden variety version of Windows 7, but with an extra touch friendly layer called Metro added on top. Many apps will have two different look -s- hence the split personality – depending if they’re running in the familiar icon-based desktop mode or in the new, colorful tile-based Metro mode.

The huge challenge could be the developers.

Now, instead of developing one version of a program, they’ll need to develop two. It’s not mandatory. A program could still run purely in desktop mode, and this will be necessary anyways for backwards compatibility. But most will want to take advantage of Metro, which represents the tablet face of Win 8.

A good example is Internet Explorer 10. CNET published a bit today comparing the two versions (“experiences”). Well, it’s one version. The Win 8 version. But with two different interfaces: the desktop interface, and the Metro interface.


Lance Whitney writes that “the Metro browser and the desktop browser can be clumsy and jarring. ” Worse still, “there’s a lack of consistency and standardization between the two. ” Uh oh. This is coming from a tech guy from a tech site. Can you imagine when Win 8 hits Mainstreet USA? Pop, goes the weasel.

There’s a lot of talk regarding Android fragmentation – the idea that too many versions of the OS are causing too many development and testing issues and slowing down progress, and ultimately the number of apps available on the platform. I used to not think much of it (What, Google Worry?), after all the market share numbers speak for themselves. Android is a smash hit – on smartphones. But with the recent Ice Cream Sandwich fiasco — hello, hello, come out wherever you are… please — I’m inclined to think that things such as too many versions of an OS floating around in the market, or a split personality such as the one we’re seeing with apps like Internet Explorer 10 in Win 8 are cautionary tales not to be ignored.

Explore. Create. Live. Follow Stark Insider on Twitter and Facebook. Join our 9,000 subscribers who read SI on tablets and smartphones on Google Newsstand. Prefer video? Subscribe to 
Stark Insider on YouTube, the largest arts & travel channel in San Francisco.
  • Crbruederle

    there is nothing on windows 8 for wireless networking.   i cant find any drivers for netgear router to work on 8 . my disk will not load in netgear like it did in win 7.

    • That’s odd. are you running consumer preview? We ran it on ThinkPad and had wireless with no problems.

  • sameer_singh17

    Agree on Windows 8. It just seems like MS was focused on protecting its PC market while trying to reach into the tablet market as well. Combining two different OSes, given you one half baked OS.

    Detailed analysis here –