Smackdown: Galaxy Nexus vs. Motorola RAZR

I was going to go RAZR (hey, nostalgia is fun), but for a feature monger like me, ICS on Nexus is hard (impossible) to turn down.

Google Samsung Nexus

Google Samsung Nexus

Just say no to iPhone.

I’m still debating which Android smartphone will replace my trusty (but aging and definitely slower these days) Moto Droid that I picked up on launch day about two years ago at a local Verizon store.

As I wrote in my comparison of the two heavyweights last week there’s a lot to like in both phones. The RAZR is … well, razor thin at only 7.1mm. But the Nexus packs ICS (Ice Cream Sandwich), version 4.0 of Google’s latest mobile OS. Being an ardent early adopter that last point may just tip the scales in favor of an upgrade to Nexus.

Regardless of what phone I pickup in the coming weeks, I’m looking forward to:

1. Faster performance – Moto Droid was fast back in the day (2009), but now feels sluggish no matter how many apps I delete, and no matter how many processes I kill. My #1 need … is for speed!

2. Larger screen – the latest class of smartphones (Bionic, we hardly knew you) are so much lighter and easier to pocket that a larger display is really a slam dunk. Case in point: Samsung Galaxy S II – it’s almost too light. Since I use my Droid every day for Nav, I’m going to appreciate a larger, more vibrant (Super AMOLED) display.

3. (Much) Improved Battery life – the battery is terrible on Droid. Quite ridiculous really. Some report they get 10+ hours on it.  I know how that goes though: turn off bluetooth, lower display brightness to minimum, don’t make phone calls, don’t send text messages… and, oh yeah- turn it off completely, then you’ll be really impressed. I envy the iPad in that respect; almost a 10-inch display and yet it can go forever. Standby doesn’t suck it dry either.

Unless some surprise announcement is forthcoming I’ve pretty much narrowed down my decision (like a lot of you out there it appears…) to either a RAZR or a Nexus. I was most certainly going to go RAZR (hey, nostalgia is fun), but for a feature monger like me, ICS on Nexus is hard (pretty much impossible) to turn down. According to some Twitter G2, RAZR will get it in January, but it’s not yet confirmed.

Since I haven’t been able to get my hands on either Android smartphone, I’ve scoured the web (like a lot of you out there it appears…) for the latest opinions, info, photos.

Here’s some of the thoughts I’ve run across.

Fonehome, across the pond, had this to say:

“The Samsung Galaxy Nexus appears to have the slightest of edges in a couple of key areas, but once the RAZR gets its Ice Cream Sandwich update things could be a lot more difficult to call. We can’t wait to see these two slim super-phones in action side by side.”

Meanwhile, the Globe & Mail up in Canada found 5 features in the Nexus that you won’t find on the iPhone:

1. Face recognition unlock

2. A true 4G network

3. Mobile payments

4. Automatically respond to calls with a text

5. A wider screen

Ubergizmo wonders if the Pentile screen on the Google Nexus is going to be that great, after all:

“It seems that the 4.65″ HD Super AMOLED display found in the Samsung Galaxy Nexus is not that “super” after all, where it will rely on the similar RGB PenTile display that is available on all Nexus devices until now instead of using the full RGB display that is found in the Super AMOLED Plus devices.”

And Geek.com has the best spec comparison I’ve seen yet between the two phones. Their summary:

“These phones have a lot in common in the specs department. As much as people were holding out for the “Nexus Prime” (which ultimately ended up being the Galaxy Nexus), the Droid Razr has snuck in and created a difficult decision for a lot of Android users.”

UPDATE: HTC REZOUND

HTC RezoundWord is that HTC will announce their version of Nexus – crappily dubbed the “Rezound” – on November 10. On its design, intomobile suggests you “grab a barf bag.”

Like RAZR, price is on top end at $299 with two year contract.

Rumored specs:

  • 4.3 inch screen
  • 1280 x 720 pixels
  • dual core 1.5 GHz processor
  • 1 GB of RAM
  • 8 megapixel camera
  • 4G LTE

But — BUT! — only Gingerbread. And my favorite quote from intomobile:

“…tell us this design doesn’t want to make you hit yourself over the head with a half empty bottle of wine?”

Imagine what you’d do if you finished the whole bottle?

Explore. Create. Live. Follow Stark Insider on Twitter and Facebook. Join our 9,000 subscribers who read SI on tablets and smartphones on Google Newsstand. Prefer video? Subscribe to 
Stark Insider on YouTube, the largest arts & travel channel in San Francisco.
  • Robert McKay

    You mentioned that you’d appreciate a Super Amoled *Plus* screen, but neither of these devices has a Plus screen. They are both regular Super Amoled. They both have a much higher resolution than previous non-plus screens and it likely won’t matter at all, but I thought you might want to correct that. 

    • Ramsinessapour

      Robert I think the razr will have the plus screen. But what I want to know what screen will look better for netflix movies and videos. The razr with the 940*460 ( something like that) with the super amoled plus ,screen or the Nexus with 1280*720 but only the super amoled screen. Any info would be great thanks

      • Here’s a pretty good rundown of the specs for both phones. Both will be using the pentile screen and thus will not be using the Amoled + moniker. So, I think I’d definitely rather have the Nexus from a screen perspective. http://www.geek.com/articles/mobile/galaxy-nexus-vs-droid-razr-how-the-specs-compare-20111024/

  • DaveM

    Any info on if or when the Razr will get ICS yet. I am also looking to upgrade and really like the look of the Razr and the fact it has a memory card slot ( don’t think the samsung nexus has) but really want to get ICS. I am in the UK so don’t think 4G will be available for about a year. I tend to stick with a phone for a long time ( still using an Omnia 2) so want the latest I can get. not 100% sure I like the size of these phones though.