Theater Review: ‘Abraham Lincoln’s Big, Gay Dance Party’

This highly amusing satire on the state of our current political discourse is really about intolerance, bigotry and hypocrisy, in no particular order.

In Review

Abraham Lincoln's Big, Gay Dance Party

3.5 out of 5 stars
3.5 out of 5 stars - 'Sweet Stuff'
City Lights Theater Company, San Jose
Directed by Gina Marie Hayes
Starring Noah Averbach-Katz, Karen DeHart, James Mantell, Alexander Prather, K. Michael Riley, Alika Ululani Spencer, Lani Carissa Wong
Written by Aaron Loeb
www.citc.org
Review by

Guest post by Pat Reardon.

Was Abraham Lincoln really gay? In spite of the title of this production, that really isn’t what the story is about. It also isn’t about a dance party. This highly amusing satire on the state of our current political discourse is really about intolerance, bigotry and hypocrisy, in no particular order. Set in conservative rural Illinois, Abraham Lincoln’s Big Gay Dance Party skewers right-wing conservative Republicans and big-town liberal Democrats equally.

The evening begins with fourth grade teacher Harmony Green’s (Karen DeHart) holiday class pageant where she substitutes the usual Christmas fare with a program about past presidents. Sounds innocent enough … that is until the part about Abe Lincoln being gay generates hysteria and brings the uber-conventional house down.

Washed-up conservative DA Jerry Hauser sees an opportunity to get back into the spotlight and further his bid for Governor by putting Harmony on trial in what is being called in that neck of the woods as ”the trial of the century”. Not to be out done, Jerry’s Republican primary opponent, defense attorney Regina Lincoln pleads for the defendant.

This ripe for the picking situation is hysterically enriched by the addition of the elitist  Pulitzer Prize-winning New York times reporter Anton Renault (Noah Averbach-Katz), Tina, an ambitious and morally compromised political assistant (Alika Ululani Spencer), Lloyd Chambers (James Mantell), a corrupt Carl Rovian political operative and Tom Hauser (Alexander Prather), the charming and innocent gay pie maker.

The performance makes liberal use of audience interaction and further engages the viewers by randomly selecting an individual to choose the order of the acts. The three act play uses the ‘same event, three different viewpoints’ strategy so it really doesn’t matter which is presented first.

The dialogue is funny, fast and snappy, and it keeps the audience on its toes. The lines are very well delivered by the talented cast as each member performs multiple roles. Prather’s intrepid reporter Walter Kopaczek is “Front Page” worthy. Alika Spencer is superb as Tina and her fourth grader rendition of George Washington is simply darling. Wong is very good as the up tight Regina Lincoln, but even better as Renault’s photographer buddy Esmeralda Diaz. Averbach-Katz is pitch-perfect as the unctuous Anton Renault.

Not all of the odd dance interludes between the scenes are perfectly performed and some seemed a bit awkward. But the two and a half hours fly by as the performers take the audience through this hysterical tale of greed, homophobia, ambition, murder and retribution. OK, it does end a bit cute in a “We CAN all get along!” kind of a way. But this production is very funny, very current and very worth seeing.

Abe Lincoln’s Big Gay Dance Party runs through December 19.

Abraham Lincoln’s Big, Gay Dance Party
3.5 out of 5 stars
Where: City Lights Theater Company, San Jose
Directed by Gina Marie Hayes
Written by Aaron Loeb
Starring Noah Averbach-Katz, Karen DeHart, James Mantell, Alexander Prather, K. Michael Riley, Alika Ululani Spencer, Lani Carissa Wong
On the web: www.citc.org

Explore. Create. Live. Follow Stark Insider on Twitter and Facebook. Join our 9,000 subscribers who read SI on tablets and smartphones on Google Newsstand. Prefer video? Subscribe to 
Stark Insider on YouTube, the largest arts & travel channel in San Francisco.
  • Dear Patricia,

    You’ve mistakenly listed Michael Riley as Tom Hauser and the small-town reporter when that part is actually played by Alexander Prather.

    Thank you,
    City Lights Theater Company

    • Thanks for the correction. The review has been updated. best, Clint