Time to upgrade to a smartphone: BlackBerry, iPhone or Android?

Motorola's mysterious iDon't marketing campaign for their new Android phone
Motorola's mysterious iDon't marketing campaign for their new Android phone

Just a few years back, it was so simple. If you wanted to stay in touch with email on the go, you got a BlackBerry. End of story. So I went from model to model, upgrading every few years, happy as a corporate clam.

Then, Apple turned the industry—as it loves to do—on its ear with the slick, sexy iPhone. It could do email too. But it also had a touch screen, built-in iPod, and this little thing called iTunes which offers an assortment of entertainment goodies, including a wildly, crazy successful App Store. Now 80,000+ apps strong.

But Google, not content to sit by and miss a good party (read: profits), jumped into the fray in 2008 with it’s young mobile OS called, nerdily enough, Android.

It was rough around the edges, with geek appeal. But just over a year later, the flood gates have opened. Why all the new Android-based models now? It’s mainly Google’s smart choice to take an open approach: many devices, many carriers. That’s why, starting this week, you can now find handsets not only on T-Mobile (which launched the first Android device, the HTC G1), but also on Sprint and Verizon.

My BlackBerry 8700, high mileage, and a few pavement bounces
My BlackBerry 8700: high mileage, and a few pavement bounces

In the long-term I think Apple will have a formidable competitor on its hands. Compare it to the PC market where Apple is a minority player, again with a proprietary, albeit high margin, vertically integrated strategy of hardware (Mac), software (Mac OS), and content (iTunes). They own you lock, stock and barrel. Hence, the user experience is supreme, the best in the industry.

However, Microsoft owns the PC market with Windows thanks to their open (or at least standards based) approach… multiple vendors can license the OS. This strategy has worked very, very well. Fat cats indeed.

So, Google with an open approach could well be headed down a market share expanding path. Multiple carriers. Multiple vendors licensing Android including: Samsung, Motorola, HTC. Big names.

Also, Android has matured significantly over the past 12 months. Many say 2010 will be a break out year. Although they have some catching up to do on the apps side with 8,000 apps on Android market, only about 10% of Apple’s offerings.

I’m not suggesting Google and Android will be iPhone killers. But, formidable competitor? Absolutely.

Okay, back to my original dilemna… what smartphone to buy?

Apple iPhone

I’ve ruled out the iPhone as much as I think it’s phenomenal. The network, AT&T, of which I’m a current customer, stinks. I constantly lose calls, can’t hear the person on the other end, etc.

BlackBerry

I like BB. It’s served me well. I can fly with my thumbs (probably not as quick as the champion, Loni) on the little chicklet keyboard. And my current phone, the solid BlackBerry 8700c (even still has the classic Cingular logo), is reliable and easy to use, but quite slow.

The new Storm 2 looks promising. But I’d like more apps. Plus I’m not sure I want to be locked in to RIM for another 2 years.

Windows Mobile

No way.

Google Android

My leading choice is Android. There’s too much to like. Growing vendor choices, and app store. Multiple, non-AT&T carriers: Sprint, T-Mobile, Verizon (big red!).

As for the phone itself, part of the decision comes down to preference for a physical keyboard. I recently visited a Sprint store in San Jose to try out the HTC Hero, a great Android phone. I couldn’t get type fast though without making a lot of typos. Maybe that would change with practice.

The models with keyboards, sliders, are appealing, but bulkier. Some new models are being released this week also, with the uber Motorola Droid running the updated Android 2.0, OS—the first phone to do so.

So far, my short list:

  • HTC Hero (Sprint)
  • Motorola CLIQ (T-Mobile)
  • Motorola Droid (Verizon)
Explore. Create. Live. Follow Stark Insider on Twitter and Facebook. Join our 9,000 subscribers who read SI on tablets and smartphones on Google Newsstand. Prefer video? Subscribe to 
Stark Insider on YouTube, the largest arts & travel channel in San Francisco.
  • Steve

    Thats a good short list. I would wait another month or even 2 before you make a decision. Theres a few more that you missed for consideration…the Behold II (Nov 18th) being one of them, and the HD2 (quite possibly the iPhone killer)…and I am being serious.

    I have had the G1 since day 1 and I am having a hard time figuring out what to upgrade to. Android is BY FAR the best mobile OS out there, and in my opinion Windows Mobile is the worst…however, the HD2 that will be releasing soon on T-Mobile might make us change both our minds about WinMobile. See what you can dig up on youtube regarding this phone and you might have a change of heart.

    • Thanks Steve for the tips. Looks like I have some more research to do (seems like it never ends). An avalanche of new models! Sounds like you're enjoying the G1.

  • Steve

    Thats a good short list. I would wait another month or even 2 before you make a decision. Theres a few more that you missed for consideration…the Behold II (Nov 18th) being one of them, and the HD2 (quite possibly the iPhone killer)…and I am being serious.

    I have had the G1 since day 1 and I am having a hard time figuring out what to upgrade to. Android is BY FAR the best mobile OS out there, and in my opinion Windows Mobile is the worst…however, the HD2 that will be releasing soon on T-Mobile might make us change both our minds about WinMobile. See what you can dig up on youtube regarding this phone and you might have a change of heart.

    • Thanks Steve for the tips. Looks like I have some more research to do (seems like it never ends). An avalanche of new models! Sounds like you're enjoying the G1.

  • Graham Zeisner

    I'm going with the Iphone 3Gs. You have opened my eyes to other possibilities however so I will check out the competition….pretty hard to ignore any Google initiative.

    • Hey Graham! Don't think you can go wrong with the 3GS. I just hope the network in Canada is better than AT&T here. I can't even make basic calls a lot of the time, and often get bumped off EDGE to GPS where I can't access my email or data. And this is… 2009?!

  • Graham Zeisner

    I'm going with the Iphone 3Gs. You have opened my eyes to other possibilities however so I will check out the competition….pretty hard to ignore any Google initiative.

    • Hey Graham! Don't think you can go wrong with the 3GS. I just hope the network in Canada is better than AT&T here. I can't even make basic calls a lot of the time, and often get bumped off EDGE to GPS where I can't access my email or data. And this is… 2009?!

  • John

    I wouldn't ignore Palm's new webOS. The pre is a sweet little machine.
    In support of android, there's the additional feel good feeling that comes with supporting open source.

  • John

    I wouldn't ignore Palm's new webOS. The pre is a sweet little machine.
    In support of android, there's the additional feel good feeling that comes with supporting open source.